Search This Blog

Friday, December 11, 2009

Foot Fetish



As many regular readers know, I began running in Vibram Five Fingers last summer, soon after reading Born to Run by Christopher McDougall.  VFFs simulate, very closely, barefoot running.  The category of shoe they fall into is labeled minimalist.  And those of us that subscribe to the theory believe that most traditional shoes or sneakers do us more damage than good.  For a deeper discussion of this issue, read Born to Run or start with this New York Times article.



Since most of us have been wearing shoes as long as we can remember, the concept takes some getting used to.  My feet, ankles, and calves also took some time to adjust.  Until I fully acclimated to the VFFs I interspersed training in my Adidas Supernovas.  Leading up to the Baystate Marathon this past October, I did about half my runs in the VFFs and half in sneakers.  Since the marathon I've 90% or more of my miles in VFFs.  But that was until the weather started getting colder.

Many months ago I joined a Minimalist Runner, a Google Group started by Barefoot Ted.  I soon realized that though I was new to minimalist running, there were many who'd been dedicated to the pursuit for years (to say nothing of the fact that humans have been running barefoot since, well, the dawn of our existence).  Knowing that there are other alternatives to VFFs I ("The Ringer") posted a question on the group bulletin board asking what I might consider wearing for winter minimalist gear.  I thought that it might offer an interesting window into the minimalist footwear subculture if I posted the replies I got to my query.  See below.




The Ringer  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 10:42 am
Hey,
I began running in VFFs last summer, but now it's 21 degrees out, snow
on the ground and today there are gusts of up to 40 MPH (I live in NE
Connecticut).  At least it's sunny outside.
I know I shouldn't admit it here, but I ran today in my Adidas
Supernovas (sacrilege, I know).  But seriously, what I can run in over
the winter, minimalist style, and not have my toes freeze off?!
The Ringer

    Reply    Reply to author    Forward  



Harry Hollines  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 11:06 am
As most know, I'm a huge fan of the Mizuno Wave Universe 3's.  In fact,
they've replaced my VFFs.  For me, they are better than VFFs and I never
thought I would say that.  And, they get better as you put more miles on
them.  In snow, you can attach coil YakTraks.  In cold weather, you can put
heat packs on top of your toes and they don't interfere.  I've run in -17F
in them also.
Just my experiences.
Harry




- Show quoted text -

--
HHH
http://hhollines.blogspot.com/
http://twitter.com/thexgen

    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



Tuck  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 11:26 am
My choice is a modified new balance mt100. the modification is to
remove the heel, it's covered in another thread here.
In a nutshell, just like a mitten is warmer than gloves...  we need
feet 'mittens' for the winter.




- Show quoted text -

--
_________________________________
Tucker

    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



G.O.  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 11:37 am
Hey Ringer I understand your dilemna!  For the moment I am wearing well worn
pair of Sauconys  while running outdoors with a pair of Gore-Tex socks
stuffed inside. I did not want to go this route but one very cold day of
running in minimal footwear quickly changed my mind and had me wondering
about my sanity.  As the weather gets colder and icier I will put duct tape
around the top of the shoe and switch to another old pair of shoes that have
screws drilled into the bottom for traction. This has worked well in the
past and has allowed me to run in conditions as cold as -56C ( with
windchill).   I plan to continue with this footwear regime until ( or if)  a
suitable pair of mukluks can be made. I am researching this possibility
before going out and buying all the materials as it is expensive and I heard
not all mukluks are suitable for running.
Gail
On 12/11/09 9:42 AM, "The Ringer" ...@gmail.com> wrote:




- Show quoted text -


    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



Highlander  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 11:53 am
Primal moccasins. I review them in the various posts here (see the
bottom post for most detail):
http://shootthemoonforbraininjury.blogspot.com/search/label/primal%20moc
In short, with a  thin wool sock, I'm toasty down to -10F, -30+
windchill. They feel closer to barefoot than anything I've run in, and
they grip surprisingly well even on snow and ice (because they conform
to the minute textures, and if you're barefoot technique is good, very
little slipping except on steep trails where I slip in anything except
strapped on chains).
Blessings,
Patrick
It's all good (but, is it the Best Good?)
www.braininjurychaplain.com
http://shootthemoonforbraininjury.blogspot.com/
On Dec 11, 8:42 am, The Ringer ...@gmail.com> wrote:




- Show quoted text -


    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



Andy Southerland  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 12:01 pm
How's the ski-skin prototype coming?
On Dec 11, 11:53 am, Highlander ...@mac.com> wrote:




- Show quoted text -


    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



John Sprocket  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 2:26 pm
I'm having trouble getting up the enthusiasm to go running in this
cold at all.
I enjoyed running all summer, and even enjoyed the Fall.  But come
winter I end up using the stationary bikes or elliptical machines at
the gym.
I just haven't found a way to enjoy the cold yet.  And it bothers me
some.
John
On Dec 11, 7:42 am, The Ringer ...@gmail.com> wrote:




- Show quoted text -


    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



Harry Hollines  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 2:46 pm
John,
Dig deep.  Make a small commitment to yourself to go out in the cold and
only commit to run 5-10 minutes (just 5-10 minutes out of your life), and I
doubt you will stop at 10 minutes.
Still to this day I use different methods to motivate myself.  This morning
I had one of my toughest combined interval & tempo training sessions and I
wanted to quit before it started and then I wanted to quit half way through
but then I kept saying "5 more minutes," and then I thought about all the
people in the world that don't have the opportunity to run or can't run in
save places, and then I thought about those folks that would be out-working
me if I did quit, and finally I said I can't be a hypocrite to my kids as I
constantly tell them not to quit so I can't.
There's many ways to get going but ultimately you have to commit to make the
first step after that each additional step gets easier.
Harry
On Fri, Dec 11, 2009 at 12:26 PM, John Sprocket ...@gmail.com>wrote:





- Show quoted text -

--
HHH
http://hhollines.blogspot.com/
http://twitter.com/thexgen

    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



Tuck  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 3:13 pm
I actually prefer running in the cold.  The first few minutes are the
toughest, but once you warm up I think it's much nicer.  No bugs, and
no snakes. ;)  Running in the snow is the nicest of all, and running
in a snowstorm is heaven.
Takes a couple of tries to get the clothing combo right, but it's well worth it.




- Show quoted text -

--
_________________________________
Tucker

    Reply    Reply to author    Forward        

     Rate this post: 



Harry Hollines  
View profile  
 More options Dec 11, 3:30 pm
I just read this and it's fitting:
"You rarely regret the runs you do; you almost always regret the runs you
skip."
Harry




- Show quoted text -

--
HHH
http://hhollines.blogspot.com/
http://twitter.com/thexgen


No comments: